Pin it
Fall flavors dance together in this hearty meal, where buttery orzo pairs with caramelized butternut squash and wilted spinach, all brought together by aromatic garlic oil and crumbly blue cheese. Each mouthful delivers a wonderful mix of textures and seasonal warmth.
After trying many versions, I found that dicing the squash into tiny, equal-sized chunks makes sure they cook evenly and blend perfectly with the pasta.
Smart Ingredient Picking Guide
- Butternut squash: Look for solid, unspotted squash with dull skin
- Orzo: Good-quality pasta that stays firm when cooked
- Spinach: Crisp, green leaves without any softness
- Blue cheese: Smooth type that breaks apart easily
- Garlic: Only whole cloves - jarred stuff won't give you the right taste
- Olive oil: Extra virgin for richer flavor
Pin it
Clear Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- Nailing the squash:
- Slice into even 1/4-inch bits. Mix well with oil and spices. Lay flat on tray. Keep pieces apart. Flip pan around halfway.
- Making the garlic oil:
- Warm oil slowly to stop burning. Keep an eye on garlic. Pull from heat when smells good. Save all garlic pieces for mixing. Let sit while cooking other stuff.
- Getting orzo right:
- Get water bubbling hard. Add plenty of salt. Stir now and then while cooking. Check often for slight firmness. Save some cooking water before pouring out.
- Putting it all together:
- Mix spinach with hot orzo right away. Add squash carefully. Pour garlic oil over top. Put cheese in last. Mix until barely combined.
From all my times making this dish, I've noticed that building flavors one by one - from sweet roasted squash to tasty oil - makes this meal something you'll remember.
Handling Heat Right
Getting temperatures right matters:
- 425°F browns squash perfectly
- Use gentle heat for the garlic oil
- Eat right away while pasta's warm
- Keep pasta water handy for warming up
Prep-Ahead Options
You can break up the cooking:
- Cut squash up to 2 days early
- Cook squash hours before serving
- Fix garlic oil ahead of time
- Mix everything together just before eating
Fixing Common Problems
Too soft orzo: Shorten cooking time. Hard squash: Cut smaller pieces. Burnt garlic taste: Use lower heat. Too dry: Splash in some saved pasta water.
Pin it
Having made this countless times, I really love how it balances homey comfort with classy flavor. The way the caramelized squash works with the tangy cheese while the garlic oil ties it all together creates something truly wonderful. Whether it's your main meal or on the side, this orzo shows that simple foods, handled with care, can turn into an amazing dish.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prepare this earlier?
- It’s best fresh, but you can refrigerate leftovers for up to 3 days. Reheat with a splash of water or broth.
- → What’s a good swap for blue cheese?
- Try feta or Parmesan if blue cheese isn’t your thing.
- → Will frozen squash work for this?
- Sure! Just keep an eye during roasting—it’ll likely cook quicker than fresh squash.
- → What pairs well with this meal?
- Serve as a main with a crisp salad or pair it as a side with grilled fish or chicken.
- → Can I use another kind of pasta?
- Absolutely! Small options like ditalini or mini shells are great stand-ins for orzo.