Pin it
This addictive starter combines zesty dill pickles with smooth, velvety cheese for a crowd-pleasing cheese ball that'll have everyone reaching for "just another taste." Every flavor component builds wonderfully, from the silky middle to the crispy outer layer, making a perfectly balanced snack.
I found that mixing in a bit of pickle brine with the ingredients, not just chopped pickles, spreads that wonderful pickle taste into every single bite.
Complete Ingredient Guide
- Cream cheese: Use only full-fat, softened to room temp for easy blending
- Cheddar cheese: Grab sharp or extra-sharp, and grate it yourself
- Pickles: Stick with crispy dill pickles, avoid the sweet varieties
- Fresh dill: Pick bunches with vibrant green stems without yellowing
- Green onions: Go for ones that feel firm with bright tops
- Sesame seeds: Buy them untoasted so you can toast them fresh
Pin it
Easy-to-Follow Preparation Guide
- Making your base:
- Let cream cheese warm up completely. Whip it until smooth with zero lumps. Drizzle in pickle juice slowly to keep the right texture. Blend in sour cream until everything's mixed well. Add salt and pepper bit by bit, tasting as you go.
- Folding in extras:
- Dice pickles small and dry them thoroughly. Cut green onions into tiny pieces. Pull dill leaves off stems and chop finely. Gently mix everything together. Sample and tweak seasonings if needed.
- Getting the shape right:
- Spread plastic wrap on your counter. Dump mixture in the middle. Use the wrap to form a ball. Twist the ends tight. Cool until solid.
- Adding the coating:
- Heat sesame seeds until lightly brown. Mix with diced cheese and dill. Roll your chilled ball in this mixture. Press down slightly so it sticks. Put back in fridge until ready to serve.
While testing different cheese balls, I realized rough-chopping the coating cheese instead of finely shredding it gives a more appealing homestyle look and better mouthfeel.
Timing Is Everything
Getting the temperature right matters:
- Allow cream cheese to soften for 1-2 hours
- Let shaped ball cool for at least 3 hours
- Take out of fridge 15-20 minutes before guests arrive
- Put leftover ball back in fridge after 2 hours out
Plan Ahead Options
This snack works great when prepared early:
- Mix everything up to 2 days before
- Keep your ball wrapped tight without coating
- Roll in coating mix right before guests come
- Store any unused coating on its own
What To Serve With It
Round out your snack table with:
- Different cracker options (buttery, whole grain, rice)
- Cut veggies for dipping
- Chunks of fresh bread
- Extra pickles on the side
Pin it
I've made tons of cheese balls over the years, but this dill pickle version really stands out with its ideal mix of smooth, tangy and crunchy elements. The way pickle flavor runs through the cheese while fresh dill adds brightness makes it so darn good. Whether you're having friends over for sports or hosting a holiday party, this cheese ball shows how simple ingredients often make the tastiest snacks.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prep this cheese ball ahead of time?
- Yup, make it up to 2 days early! It tastes even better after sitting overnight.
- → What pickles are best here?
- Go for tangy dill pickles, but whatever pickle you like will work too.
- → Can this cheese ball go in the freezer?
- It's possible but not ideal. Freezing can change the texture, so enjoy it fresh or refrigerated.
- → What should I serve with it?
- Try crackers, pretzels, tortilla chips, or veggie slices like carrots and celery.
- → Is low-fat cream cheese okay?
- Full-fat cream cheese works best, but you can mix it with low-fat. Don’t use one with less than 16-17% fat.